Personalized photo puzzles make wonderful gifts that are available from a number of retailers. You may be wondering where you can get good-quality custom made puzzles. Because Costco sells just about everything with affordable price points, it’s reasonable to wonder if they offer a service that lets you make your own puzzle with photos

Interestingly, Costco has since removed its Photo Center offerings and replaced it with a partnership with Shutterfly. Any Costco membership will give you a discount to Shutterfly’s photo print and gift services. Shutterfly is known for personalized photo gifts like t-shirts, mugs, ornaments, and puzzles. 

Does Costco Make Puzzles From Photos? Premium Custom Puzzles | MakeYourPuzzles

Shutterfly Puzzle Quality

Affordability is only one aspect of creating custom photo puzzles. The higher the quality of your puzzle, the longer it will last and the more you will enjoy it. Let’s consider what you get when you convert a photo to a puzzle with Shutterfly. 

Printing and Manufacturing Process

Shutterfly undoubtedly offers a high standard of printing for its personalized goods. While its puzzles are printed and assembled in the US, its puzzle boards are not premium quality and are manufactured abroad.  


With Shutterfly, you can add text and choose from various templates, but its customization features are more basic, straightforward and focused on their aesthetic and designs. There is no option to customize the puzzle box the puzzle comes in, or add any clip art or graphics.

How MakeYourPuzzles Leads the Pack

MakeYourPuzzles offers fully customized photo jigsaw puzzles with a commitment to premium quality and sustainable practices–perfect for any occasion, holiday, and skill level!

Eco-Friendly Manufacturing and Printing

Our puzzles are made using the latest digital printing technology with eco-friendly inks and 100% recycled ‘stay-flat’ puzzle board. Even the puzzle bag is biodegradable! Our puzzles are printed, cut, assembled, and distributed right here in the US. Our puzzles are built to stand the test of time to be enjoyed over and over.

Our puzzles are made using the latest digital printing technology with eco-friendly inks and 100% recycled ‘stay-flat’ puzzle board | MakeYourPuzzles


MakeYourPuzzles offers photo puzzles that are uniquely designed–by you! Our puzzles come in a range of sizes and piece counts, from forty-eight to 1,000 pieces, making them suitable for both children and adults. Our custom puzzle maker tool is simple and intuitive to use when it comes to choosing templates, uploading and arranging photos, and adding text and graphics. 

Additionally, our puzzle boxes can be fully customized to give your puzzle that extra edge with a store-bought finish. The process of designing your puzzle is meant to be creative and inspiring, so have fun with it!


MakeYourPuzzles offers beautiful custom photo puzzles without sacrificing quality at price points for every budget. We also include free shipping for all domestic orders. 

Photo jigsaw puzzles are a fantastic gift to give that are entertaining and collaborative for the whole family to enjoy. Whether you are designing a puzzle for a beginner or seasoned puzzler, MakeYourPuzzles has something for everyone. 

We’d love to help you get started creating the perfect custom photo puzzle–contact us today with any ideas or questions. Our dedicated team is ready to bring your personalized gift to life!

Custom Puzzles | Picture Puzzles | Premium Quality Puzzles | MakeYourPuzzles


Custom Puzzle Categories

Save Up To 53%

Best Price Guarantee

Free Shipping

On All Orders In The USA

Secured Checkout

certified Level 1 PCI DSS

Made in the USA

Premium Quality
WE ACCEPT American Express Diners Club Discover Mastercard PayPal Shop Pay Visa Amazon Google Pay Apple Pay