Make Your Custom Jigsaw Puzzle

1000 pieces
500 pieces
252 pieces
100 pieces
48 pieces

Custom photo puzzles are a timeless, thoughtful, and fun keepsake perfect for any gift or occasion. 

There are many websites that sell custom photo jigsaw puzzles and other personalized photo gifts. What is important to understand when ordering a custom-made photo puzzle is the quality of the product, customization features, price, and overall manufacturing process. You may find that although photo puzzles are popular, not all photo puzzles are created equal.

What Is The Best High-Quality Custom Photo Puzzle Website - MakeYourPuzzles

Understand the Values of the Puzzle Maker

MakeYourPuzzles is a women-owned company that produces premium-quality custom photo jigsaw puzzles in the United States. Our mission is to deliver affordable puzzles using sustainable and eco-friendly inks, materials, and production processes. 

Our puzzle-making tool is intuitive and user-friendly. It will guide you in creating unique puzzles using your favorite memories. We have nearly one hundred templates to choose from, whether you are commemorating a loved one or gifting a Mother’s Day image picture puzzle. Our platform allows you to easily upload and arrange multiple photos, add any text or graphics, and even customize your puzzle box!


Mother's Day Image Picture Puzzle - MakeYourPuzzles

How We Compare With Others

With so many companies to choose from, it can be hard to sort through the available options and features. Here, we’ll break down some custom photo puzzle websites you may have heard of or used in the past.


While Shutterfly uses a high-quality printing process on its custom photo puzzles, it does not check all of the boxes you get with MakeYourPuzzles. The site allows users to build a variety of jigsaw puzzles from their favorite photos, but lacks customization features such as text, graphics, and box design. Because puzzles are not the only product they offer, there is also less emphasis on the quality of the materials used to make the puzzle board, and their puzzles are not manufactured in the United States.


You will likely recognize Ravensberger puzzles stocked in stores where puzzles are sold. This manufacturer also offers its customers the ability to create custom photo puzzles. While they do offer a well-made product, their puzzles come at a higher price point and are made in and shipped from Germany. The puzzle-making tool also lacks many of the customization features found on the MakeYourPuzzles platform.


Similar to Shutterfly, Snapfish has a variety of custom photo offerings in addition to jigsaw puzzles. Their puzzle maker allows some customization, but there is no option to customize the box. Their puzzles are also not 100% made in the United States.


Even though they offer personalized puzzles and a range of customization options, PuzzleYOU is similar to Shutterfly and Snapfish in their manufacturing processes. PuzzleYOU puzzles are assembled in the United States but made in Europe.

Why MakeYourPuzzles Stands Out

MakeYourPuzzles is committed to manufacturing beautiful custom photo puzzles at affordable prices that will last you and your family a lifetime. Our puzzles are easy (and fun) to make, fully customizable, and made using premium-quality, stay-flat puzzle boards. 

From manufacturing to product assembly, our puzzles are made right here in the United States and are fully recyclable and eco-friendly. We offer free shipping on all domestic orders, so get started and create your high-quality custom photo puzzle today!

Best Custom Puzzles Made in the USA - MakeYourPuzzles


Custom Puzzle Categories

Save Up To 53%

Best Price Guarantee

Free Shipping

On All Orders In The USA

Secured Checkout

certified Level 1 PCI DSS

Made in the USA

Premium Quality
WE ACCEPT American Express Diners Club Discover Mastercard PayPal Shop Pay Visa Amazon Google Pay Apple Pay